
by Joseph Ford Cotto
The midterms handed Republicans an astronomical defeat. Democrats took both houses of Congress and numerous statehouses. The GOP’s registration edge in key locales failed to deliver the results many politicos anticipated. Some powerful Republican voices treat that outcome as proof it is time to move on from President Donald J. Trump.
They are wrong. Bigly.
Forsaking him would shatter the coalition that holds the party together. I collaborated with the Democracy Institute (DI), which foretold Brexit and Trump’s 2016 victory, on the surveys that prove this. Those polls make clear that Trump remains the center of gravity for Republican base loyalty, turnout, and the choice of the 2028 presidential nominee. Unity behind him is the only path that keeps the GOP competitive.
I know what I see when I see it.
My Five-Point Forecast correctly called Trump’s national victory and his triumph in every swing state two years ago. This was done by reality checks rather than outdated checklists: economic sentiment, employment, energy prices, perceptions of government response, and polling reliability. However, I knew my finance-driven model would never be a match for the lower-turnout midterms, which are characterized by partisan base voter motivation. This varies not just by state, but by district.
Last month, I used a separate registration-and-historical-turnout model, limited to Florida, where I was born, raised, and reside. It projected a modest GOP-leaning electorate. It accurately assessed that Republicans would hold all statewide offices, though by reduced margins from the 2022 midterms. Furthermore, my model correctly warned that Democrats might win various congressional seats and end the GOP’s state legislative supermajority.
With this track record, I say the following: Republicans cannot afford to abandon Trump. The DI polls, whose questions I wrote, show exactly why.
In my May survey of 910 self-identified Republican likely voters, nearly four-in-five said Trump’s record on issues outside the economy outweighed his economic handling. Focusing solely on those non-economic actions, almost nine-in-10 still judged him worthy of support. More than five-in-six said they would vote mainly on that non-financial record, even if the economy never surged.
Ninety-four percent expected other Republicans to turn out primarily for Trump himself, rather than local candidates.
His second term has already strengthened, not weakened, the bulk of the GOP electorate’s attachment to the party. My November exit poll of 450 Republican voters found that 82 percent became more supportive of the GOP due to Trump 2.0. Only 18 percent felt less supportive. Forsaking him discards the gargantuan majority who have grown more invested in the GOP because of Trump.
The red coalition’s loyalty is durable and largely independent of short-term economic performance. That same exit poll showed 71 percent of Republicans are likely to vote red in 2028, regardless of how the economy performs. Only 29 percent said their 2028 vote might hinge on economics. Fifty-seven percent of Republicans base their Trump support on non-economic issues, versus 43 percent who back him primarily for fiscal reasons.
The May results were sharper still.
Abandoning Trump severs the non-financial bond that unites most of the Republican base. Even under fiscal pressure, 86 percent of GOP likely voters said they would still vote red, based on the president’s non-economic record. Therefore, Republicans’ midterm meltdown does not justify any break from Trump.
A clear majority of Republican voters already treat a Trump endorsement as a decisive signal for the 2028 presidential primary. In my November exit poll, 68 percent said Trump’s endorsement would guide their primary vote. That single figure demonstrates his ongoing capacity to shape the actual red electorate.
The Republican base intends to stay put after Trump leaves office, provided the GOP does not break with him first. Eighty-one percent of respondents said they will continue supporting Republicans after the Trump presidency ends. That attachment has been reinforced by his second term. Continuity with his direction, not rupture from it, preserves this post-presidency loyalty.
Republican voters prioritize turnout for Trump personally over generic party or candidate loyalty. Combined with the 82 percent who are more GOP-supportive thanks to him, this proves that Trump remains the principal red mobilizing figure. A nominee selected without his involvement, or against his preference, may implode the Republican ranks.
The anti-Trump GOP faction is small. It does not constitute a viable alternative red coalition. Only 18 percent of Republican voters, per my exit poll, reported feeling less supportive of the GOP due to Trump’s administration. Only 12 percent, in my May poll, said he was unworthy of support, when non-economic actions alone were considered.
Building a 2028 strategy around this minority would decimate the GOP. Trump’s endorsement power and the base’s non-economic loyalty render him the single most important filter for electability during 2028. Almost seven-in-10 Republicans say his endorsement will guide their primary choice. Over eight-in-10 plan to remain GOP after Trump leaves office. Therefore, any anti-Trump red presidential contenders face a crippling deficit among the Republicans who actually cast ballots.
The data show Trump is not a fading figure, but the remaining center of gravity for GOP base cohesion.
The red midterm quagmire was turnout, not a rejection of Trump by Republicans who voted. The SSRS Voter Poll found Democrats and blue-leaners at 49 percent of the electorate, versus 43 percent for Republicans and red-leaners. Loyalty held when people showed up: Democrats 98 to two, Republicans 92 to seven. Pure independents were only eight percent and broke blue by 26 points.
Former Vice President Kamala Harris’s 2024 voters made up 49 percent of 2026 voters. Trump’s 2024 voters were 44 percent. Trump won the popular vote in 2024, yet his voters formed a radically smaller share of the midterm electorate. Only about seven percent of Trump voters crossed over to a Democratic congressional candidate.
Another of my DI surveys, this one from September, featured 1,500 likely voters. It showed mixed economic perceptions among the general electorate, with nearly even blame for high prices between Trump and Former President Joe Biden. There was a narrow Democratic edge on controlling inflation, despite it reaching a four-decade high under Biden-Harris. Among Republicans, however, the non-economic bond to Trump, and his GOP, was resilient.
The cumulative picture from the Democracy Institute polls I authored is that Republican electoral strength is concentrated among voters who continually stand with Trump. Taken together, these results indicate that forsaking him would not beget a broader coalition. It would fracture the one which loyal red voters find worth their while. Raising the middle finger to them, by hijacking the GOP in furtherance of anti-Trump agitation, would be manna from heaven for the Democrats.
Republican politicos yearning to disavow Trump ignore the cold, hard math. They endanger their party’s future and the welfare of America herself. There is no telling what nation-wrecking Democrats, now more radical than ever, might do if they win the presidency and Congress in 2028.
A united GOP, with President Trump at its helm, offers the only realistic path away from this midterm season’s wreckage. Abandoning him offers Republican infighting and national catastrophe. For the good of America, Republicans should put their differences aside by refusing to undermine the White House.
If that is not done, then Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez may be running it in January 2029.
Dr. Joseph Ford Cotto is the creator, host, and producer of News Sight, delivering sharp insights on the key events that shape our lives. He publishes Dr. Cotto’s Digest, sharing how business and the economy really impact us all. During the 2024 presidential race, he developed the Five-Point Forecast, which accurately predicted Donald Trump’s national victory and correctly called every swing state. Cotto holds a doctorate in business administration and is a Lean Six Sigma Certified Black Belt.

Mr.BadGuy
Publisher
Mr.BadGuy
Publisher
These soldiers are from a country whose president is a Jew Zelensky. Orthodox churches are also being destroyed in this country. Synagogues are not touched. Surprisingly, it turns out that Jews get along well with the Bandera Nazis.